The author of The Soong Dynasty gives us our most vivid and reliable biography yet of the Dowager Empress Tzu Hsi, remembered through the exaggeration and falsehood of legend as the ruthless Manchu concubine who seduced and murdered her way to the Chinese throne in 1861.
The author of The Soong Dynasty gives us our most vivid and reliable biography yet of the Dowager Empress Tzu Hsi, remembered through the exaggeration and falsehood of legend as the ruthless Manchu concubine who seduced and murdered her way to the Chinese throne in 1861.
The Dowager Empress Tzu Hsi, ruling from behind the silk curtain, held extraordinary power during the last decades of China's tottering empire. Her name has always been linked with unflattering adjectives like ruthless and cunning. Now, Seagrave explains why the woman has had such a bad press. In this quite irresistible history, the author argues that it was a trio of Englishmen who were ruthless and cunning, and it was through their flawed and distorted reporting on the court that Tzu Hsi received the bum rap from which she has never recovered. Seagrave's revisionism is based on the earlier revelations of Hugh Trevor-Roper's Hermit of Peking ( LJ 4/1/77), itself a lively book, but Seagrave is matchless when it comes to turning avid research into engaging history. Wonderful for the general reader (a helpful cast of some 200 characters is provided) but the book also has the notes and bibliography of a scholarly study.-- John H. Boyle, California State Univ., Chico
More Reviews and RecommendationsReader Rating:
See Detailed Ratings
May 29, 2009: As at May 2009 this is still the latest substantial biography on the Empress Dowager. Sterling Seagrave in this very thoroughly-researched biography of the Empress Dowager has presented compelling evidence that the traditional view that the Dowager was all powerful and evil was based on false facts mainly concocted by Sir Edmund Backhouse. The evidence he presented was that the Dowager was powerless and surrounded by powerful men who had their own agenda and aims.
The strength of this book is that it is not confined to the life of the Dowager. This is understandable as so little is known of her life. We do not even know her name. When she became Empress Dowager, she was known by the title Tzu Hsi, meaning Empress of the West, because she lived in pavilions on the west side of the Forbidden City. (see p18-19 )This book also described the events of Manchu China from the two infamous Opium Wars carried out by the English to the Boxer Rebellion/ Uprising (a misnomer as there was no rebellion/ uprising. The Boxers' aim was to exterminate all Chinese Christians and the foreign missionaries and not to overthrow the Manchu Empire). This book also described in detail the lives of Sir Robert Hart and Dr George Ernest Morrison in China. Hart came to China age 19. He was an Irishman who loved China. He rose to become a trusted confidant of the Manchu court and was the Inspector General of Chinese Customs from 1861 age 26 till 1908 age 73 when he finally decided to leave China forever. He died in England in 1911 while preparing to return to China to finish his life in his beloved China. (See pages 146, 419 and 453). Dr Morrison was the correspondent for the Times of London.I commend the writers for their dilligence and scholarship.Reader Rating:
See Detailed Ratings
December 05, 2000: This is an outstanding and extremely detailed nonfiction which highlights almost every single historical event (at least to me, it seem like it) that occured during Tzu Hsi's reign. It describes how the corruption between the royal princes and ministers lead to the fall of the Ching Dynasty, and what the real life as the secluded empress dowager lived. Although many of these events, such as the Boxer Uprising, helped somewhat a little in understanding Tzu Hsi, I personally felt that it was not worth hundreds of hours trying to read through details of small battles. I was attracted to this book because of its caption, 'The Life and Legend of the Last Empress of China,' not other political happenings during her life. The book could have been shorten to a quarter of its present quantity. However, I would like to congratulate Seagrave's defense of how Tzu Hsi wasn't an evil and murderous woman, displacing unaccounted writings of Bland and Backhouse. I strongly recommend this book for students studying China during Tzu Hsi's time, but not as strong to those who wish to read solely about Tzu Hsi.