An up-to-date and detailed eyewitness account of Burma's Civil War. It is indispensable for understanding the travails of modern Burma.
The beginning begs one to follow the author into Burma, and the last chapter, which reviews existing interpretations and solutions not laid out in such a clear way before, picks up threads that seem promising and establishes a launching pad for new thinking. This is a must read for anyone wishing to catch up on Burma's past, to learn what scholars recommend as ways out of the present and directions to follow to look to the future.
More Reviews and RecommendationsShelby Tucker has travelled widely in Burma researching this book. During his time in the country he was captured by the Burmese Communist Party and interviewed most of the leaders of Burma’s ethnic insurgents. He read law at Oxford University, and he is also the author of Among Insurgents: Walking Through Burma.
Reader Rating:
See Detailed Ratings
September 15, 2006: Tucker's Burma: the Curse of Independence reads like a hodgepodge of the author's preferred features of Burmese politics and pages of Burmese history. Although kudos are in order for the author's detailed descriptions of some events and phenomena, the book generally fails to maintain consistency and coherence and, in this reviewer's opinion, falls short of answering the central question of its title, i.e. why independence became a curse for Burma. Tucker spends much time laying out the particularly of opium trade in 'Narcocrats' to then skirt down to a bare few pages the chapter 'Kleptocrats' which seems to be there to merely sound the two off of each other. The final chapter entitled 'Wither Burma?' seems to raise a slew of issues that should have been raised in the main part of the manuscript and then leaves them hanging out there on a 'wing and a prayer'. Overall, the book is more of an opinion than a scholarly study of Burma and should be understood and treated as such.