(Paperback)
Fifteen original tales of "what if"
Some of today's top science fiction writers explore the futures that might have been, including original stories from Julie E. Czerneda and other great names in the genre.
What ifa? Every one of the 15 stories in this collection asks this question in a different way. What if the transmission of the Black Plague by fleas had been discovered earlier? What if lasers had been invented sooner? But the basic question each one of them asks is what if the past had unfolded differently? The authors of these stories explore a variety of historical and scientific possibilities. Readers will be touched by Dorranna Durgin's "A Call from the Wild," a heart-wrenching story about what would have happened if the dog had not been domesticated and had instead become a creature to be feared and even hated. In "Silent Leonardo," Kage Baker asks what might have happened to the practices of warfare if Leonardo Da Vinci's brilliant ideas had not remained merely visions, but had rather been carried out by those who recognized their brilliance. In "Site Fourteen" by Laura Anne Gilman, we see what might have happened if the race to explore space was replaced by the desire to explore the deepest parts of the ocean. These stories would have a great curricular advantage in many subject areas. History, science, and even math classes could use them as supplementary material to their lessons. Each of the stories has a "Revision Point" that explains how the past actually unfolded, so that readers can get an idea of where the changes lie within the story. This is an entertaining collection that is also quite educational despite (or perhaps even because of) the historical revisions. KLIATT Codes: SARecommended for senior high school students, advanced students, and adults. 2004, Penguin, DAW, 312p., Ages 15 to adult.
More Reviews and RecommendationsReader Rating:
See Detailed Ratings
January 19, 2005: Most of the stories take place in modern times, detailing how life would be different if historical events were slightly altered. The best of these is 'Herd Mentality'. The idea works best in 'The Resonance of Light', in which history unfolds as we know it, but near the end of the tale, an alternate event transpires and we are left to wonder about the consequences. Skip 'Axial Axioms'. Instead of a short story, this one is just a series of disconnected set-ups for puns that only a mathematician would (maybe) love.
Reader Rating:
See Detailed Ratings
July 19, 2004: This fifteen short story collection contains what if alternate history tales that will delight genre fans. Each tale takes a key scientific or technological element and changes when it occurred so that it either intersects at an earlier pivotal moment in history such as the Sumerians inventing the printing press in BC or never materialized such as Galileo fails to release his findings. The tales are all well written and the explanation of the REVISION point is fun to follow to ascertain whether the reader agrees with the author?s logic. Intriguing are those with a modern aspect to include Tesla inventing a laser in the nineteenth century, Livingstone bringing AIDS out of Africa in the nineteenth century and the government pushing aquanauts over astronauts and banning the Internet. Mindful of the Marvel Comics What If series, this terrific collection will have the audience thinking of new ones such as what if an underpaid over paid book reviewer was given a guitar instead of Narnia?---- Harriet Klausner