Table of Contents
| Contributors | |
| Preface to the Fifth Edition | |
| 1 | How to Use the Handbook | |
| 2 | How to Think about Quality | |
| 3 | The Quality Planning Process | |
| 4 | The Quality Control Process | |
| 5 | The Quality Improvement Process | |
| 6 | Process Management | |
| 7 | Quality and Income | |
| 8 | Quality and Costs | |
| 9 | Measurement, Information, and Decision-Making | |
| 10 | Computer Applications to Quality Systems | |
| 11 | The ISO 9000 Family of International Standards | |
| 12 | Benchmarking | |
| 13 | Strategic Deployment | |
| 14 | Total Quality Management | |
| 15 | Human Resources and Quality | |
| 16 | Training for Quality | |
| 17 | Project Management and Product Development | |
| 18 | Market Research and Marketing | |
| 19 | Quality in Research and Development | |
| 20 | Software Development | |
| 21 | Supplier Relations | |
| 22 | Operations | |
| 23 | Inspection and Test | |
| 24 | Job Shop Industries | |
| 25 | Customer Service | |
| 26 | Administrative and Support Operations | |
| 27 | Process Industries | |
| 28 | Quality in a High Tech Industry | |
| 29 | Automotive Industry | |
| 30 | Travel and Hospitality Industries | |
| 31 | Government Services | |
| 32 | Health Care Services | |
| 33 | Financial Services Industries | |
| 34 | Second-Generation Data Quality Systems | |
| 35 | Quality and Society | |
| 36 | Quality and the National Culture | |
| 37 | Quality in Developing Countries | |
| 38 | Quality in Western Europe | |
| 39 | Quality in Central and Eastern Europe | |
| 40 | Quality in the United States | |
| 41 | Quality in Japan | |
| 42 | Quality in the People's Republic of China | |
| 43 | Quality in Latin America | |
| 44 | Basic Statistical Methods | |
| 45 | Statistical Process Control | |
| 46 | Acceptance Sampling | |
| 47 | Design and Analysis of Experiments | |
| 48 | Reliability Concepts and Data Analysis | |
| App. I | Glossary of Symbols and Abbreviations | |
| App. II | Tables and Charts | |
| App. III | Selected Quality Standards, Specifications, and Related Documents | |
| App. IV | Quality Systems Terminology | |
| App. V | Quality Improvement Tools | |
Read an Excerpt
Section 25: Customer Service
...Considerations of Quality in Customer Service
There are four important areas where quality must be considered in customer service: strategic intent, design, organizational structure, and operations. The first is
strategic intent. As part of a strategy formulation, the overall approach to quality is determined for the product or service. A subset of the overall approach is the use of customer service elements as strategic differentiators. Examples of marketplace advantages that may be achieved by providing value-added customer service are reduced customer turnover, increased repurchasing performance, increased product or service use, and customer referrals. Value-adding customer service also may yield higher profit margins and growth in market share. The customer service strategy is determined as part of the annual business planning cycle or as part of the product planning cycle. Customer service elements are hypothesized based on insights from the available body of knowledge about the industry and its marketplace. The insights are then verified using systematic methods. The results of the verification step may be confirmation that the proposed approaches to customer service indeed are opportunities to achieve marketplace advantages or that modified or alternative approaches yield more value-adding capability. Iteration may be required until there is closure and consensus on the strategy to be undertaken.
The second important area where quality must be considered is the design area. Companies that emphasize customer service design customer service capabilities as part of the product/service life cycle. Structures andprocesses are devised during the design phase to implement the strategy for customer service that was determined in the strategy formulation. The approach to design that is presented here is patterned after the service systems engineering framework of Pyzdek. Pyzdek's framework combines concepts and methods from the systems engineering, organizational design, and behavioral science fields. All these components are important to achieve an effective design of customer service delivery capabilities.
The third area where quality must be considered is organizational structure. This is where quality is built into the organization's customer service delivery structure according to the requirements of the product or service life-cycle design. Important considerations are enabling technologies and training, process engineering and reengineering, legacy migration, and outsourcing. It is common to find that process models for customer service capabilities involve almost every business function and, therefore, almost every part of the organization. This creates an opportunity to use customer service as an integrating force that knits together a company's quality thrust. However, in many firms this pervasive characteristic also creates a problem of distributed responsibility and accountability for effective customer service.
The last important area where quality must be considered is the operational area. This is where results are achieved, measured, and improved. The ongoing performance of operating customer service processes is important here and includes such considerations as human performance, process control, process capability, process improvement, and performance metrics. Three areas of consideration dominate an effective end-to-end life-cycle design. The first includes continuous communication, reward, recognition, and development of customer-facing associates; second is continuous oversight of processes in search of stress cracks that may be caused by saturated processes, by changes in customer needs, or by other considerations not congruent with the design intent and implementation criteria; and the third is continual environmental scans in search of early warning signs of changing markets, of new opportunities, and of new competitive threats. Common to all these considerations is the need for instrumentation for collection and analysis of information.
Here I present a model that features customer service as a strategic differentiator. To illustrate the use of the model, data and examples are provided, taken from the literature, from published benchmarks, and from Baldrige Award-winning companies. The reader may wish to review the contents of Sections 3, 13, and 18 as preparation for this topic.
The model presented in Figure 25.1 helps us visualize customer service as a vehicle to achieve strategic goals and objectives for a product or a service or for a family of products or services. During the planning period for a specific product, or during the annual business planning interval for the forthcoming year, customer service is proposed as a competitive differentiator. The elements of customer service that may be appropriate for the particular type of product or service are selected. These elements are a subset of the assumed KCSs for the product or service. Insight for this inductive step may come from experience with previous products, from customer feedback such as complaint or suggestion data, from competitive analyses and environmental scans, or from new technology or business capabilities. A structured approach for this step, called service blueprinting, is described below, under Strategic Intent, AT&T Universal Card Services.
At this point in the strategy development, these insights should be verified. This verification step often is omitted, leaving the ultimate verification to the marketplace. This sometimes turns out to be an expensive shortcut. Therefore, every effort should be made to obtain verification. KCS data for the industry or for the specific product or service must be acquired. Identifying and addressing the key customer satisfiers constitute an essential step toward achieving customer satisfaction. KCS data are acquired from market research studies conducted in appropriately defined market segments. The KCS data provide insight into the specific product and service attributes that are important to customers in each market segment and the degree of importance the customers attach to each attribute. Depending on the industry, on its marketplace characteristics, and on the particular type of the product or service, one or both of two types of market research are commonly used for this purpose (see Section 18).
In many cases, it is possible to verify the proposed KCSs by using such preimplementation techniques as focus groups or market research surveys or by limited prototyping experiences. In other cases, it may be necessary to use a rapid cycle-time implementation of initial production to get feedback. This is called a beta test in some industries. A more traditional term is field trial. These alternatives are illustrated in an expansion of the Lisrel model as shown in Figure 25.2.
The well-known quality function deployment technique often is used as the vehicle to integrate two important steps, the understanding of what is important to customers in market segments (e.g., KCS data) and the correlation of the important attributes, stated in terms meaningful to the customer, with specific product and service attributes, stated in terms that are meaningful to the designer (see Section 3).
When the strategic approach to customer service is verified, improved and updated, and documented, it is usually included in a preliminary business case.
AT&T Universal Card Services
The Universal Card Services business unit of AT&T provides an impressive example. From the time the business was first created in March 1990, it took only 30 months to become the second largest credit card issuer in the United States. How did AT&T differentiate what had been a commodity product and service? What prompted AT&T at the outset to rush in and try to establish a winning credit card business? AT&T was looking for ways to reinforce brand loyalty for long-distance calling services. A credit card that is also a calling card seemed like a natural marriage. However, there were hurdles to overcome. Customers were not satisfied with the credit cards that they had. Card users did not like the high fees, and they did not generally like the service that they received. They complained angrily about surly service representatives who took weeks to process changes and who embroiled anxious customers who had lost their cards in tangles of paperwork and phone calls. AT&T asserted that it could do better. Using the service blueprinting process, described below, AT&T chose a differentiating capability that had never been provided to credit card owners in the past: world-class customer service. To differentiate the customer service significantly, several important moments of truth in the customer service blueprints were selected. Market research studies showed clearly that one moment of truth would not have been enough.
The blueprinting process is illustrated and summarized in Figure 25.3. The blueprint is usually recorded as a flowchart of the particular process under study. The flowchart is segmented to clearly illustrate the lines of interaction between the service and the customer and the so-called line of invisibility. The line of invisibility is the boundary between the directly customer-facing subprocesses and the "back-office" subprocesses that support the customer-facing elements. Using the blueprint diagram, it becomes possible to answer the questions summarized in the bullet list in Figure 25.3. These answers provide the basis for selecting key moments of truth and for making other implementation decisions.
The service blueprint, which was implemented as a process, included fast, accurate, supportive, and helpful customer service representatives. The service representatives are empowered and rewarded for helping customers. First, a rigorous daily customer satisfaction measurement process was put in place, coupled with a daily bonus plan. Figure 25.4 offers an example of bonuses actually received during a period of time. On those days when the service representatives do not receive their bonus, no manager receives a bonus. Second, the customer service processes are supported by leading-edge technology. This gives the service representatives easy and rapid access to all the information that could possibly be needed in support of the customer. Third, the customers are given differentiating value in the form of lower interest rates than are provided by any other vendor. And fourth, the company undertook the role of the agent of the customer in relationships with credit bureaus and other users of credit information.
In recent years, AT&T Universal Card Services has initiated more than 300,000 new accounts per month. This growth stems in part from the sales story that is part of the front-end, customer relationship-building process. It also comes from finely tuned customer service operations that also were part of the strategic design of the business and which have been improved and enhanced over time. This customer service strategy was part of AT&T's Baldrige Award-winning approach.
...