An Instance of the Fingerpost by Iain Pears

BUY IT NEW

  • $8.99 Online price
    $8.09 Member price
    (Save 10%)
    Limited Time Offer! Everyone receives the Member Price on books.
    See Details
  • skip to cart
  • Add To List uiAction=GetAllLists&page=List&pageType=list&ean=9780425167724&productCode=BK&maxCount=100&threshold=3

GET FREE SHIPPING ON ORDERS OF $25 OR MORE

DELIVERY & GIFT DETAILS:

Usually ships within 24 hours

Delivery Time and Shipping Rates

Eligible for gift wrap & gift message.

BUY IT USED

381 copies from $1.99

See All Available

Pick Me Up

Reserve it at BN.com & pick it up in 60 minutes at your local store.

Enter a zip code

(Mass Market Paperback)

  • Pub. Date: March 1999
  • 752pp
  • Sales Rank: 33,565
B&N Discover Great New Writers

    Reader Rating: (22 ratings)

    Detailed Rating: "Characters" See All

    More Formats 
    Paperback - Reprint$12.80
    Buy it Used: 381 copies from $1.99 See All Available

    Customers who bought this also bought

     
    • Overview
    • Editorial Reviews
    • Customer Reviews
    • Meet the Writer
    • Features

    Product Details

    • Pub. Date: March 1999
    • Publisher: Penguin Group (USA)
    • Format: Mass Market Paperback, 752pp
    • Sales Rank: 33,565

    Synopsis

    We are in Oxford in the 1660s - a time, and place, of great intellectual, scientific, religious and political ferment. Robert Grove, a fellow of New College is found dead in suspicious circumstances. A young woman is accused of his murder. We hear about the events surrounding his death from four witnesses: Marco da Cola, a Venetian Catholic intent on claiming credit for the invention of blood transfusion; Jack Prescott, the son of a supposed traitor to the Royalist cause determined to vindicate his father; John Wallis, chief cryptographer to both Cromwell and Charles II, a mathematician, theologican and inveterate plotter; and Anthony Wood, the famous Oxford antiquary. Each witness tells their version of what happened. Only one reveals the extraordinary truth.

    An Instance of the Fingerpost is a magnificent tour de force: an utterly compelling historical mystery story with a plot that twists and turns and keeps the reader guessing until the very last page.


    From the Trade Paperback edition.

    Daniel Reitz

    Riverhead is marketing the hell out of historian Iain Pears' first novel, An Instance of the Fingerpost, and the media seems turned on by the hype -- you'd almost believe this was "the literary thriller of the year." Don't be surprised if midway through this sprawling and seemingly endless tome, however, you feel like suing the publishers (and certain critics) for fraud. If this book is a thriller, then I'm Edgar Allan Poe.

    For Pears and certain other moderately talented writers, history provides a sturdy hook to hang a shabby coat upon. It gives a sense of legitimacy -- even intellectual clout -- to writers such as Caleb Carr, whose novels are trotted out with Umberto Eco-ish pretensions. (In Carr's case, it's the jacket designer and the marketers who are the real artists, gulling readers into thinking it must be literature because Theodore Roosevelt figures as a character, there's an Alfred Stieglitz photograph on the cover and it's over 400 pages long.) Pears, as it happens, is no Caleb Carr. He's much more boring than that.

    An Instance of the Fingerpost is a Rashomon-like tale that deconstructs a murder in 1660s Oxford and the trial that leads a young woman to be hanged for a crime she didn't commit. (Or did she?) Every section is narrated by a different character -- although each tends to sound much the same as those that came before -- and each narrator reevaluates the version of events you've just read, giving his spin on what is true, each assuring you that he alone is telling you the truth. The problem is that you're getting multiple versions of a story that Pears hasn't convinced you to care about in the first place. The narrators are a motley collection of pompous gasbags, and Pears' approach is to present each rambling section as if we've just stumbled on some actual 16th century historical documents -- every word is supposedly both fascinating and important.

    Pears may be a better writer than Carr, but he's sanctimonious where Carr tends to be overly manipulative. The point of his novel seems best summed up when one of the ponderous speakers tells us, "We are all capable of the most monstrous evil when convinced we are right, and it was an age when the madness of conviction held all tightly in its grasp." This is a noble sentiment, to be sure, but after a century of Stalin, Hitler and Mao, it's not particularly revelatory. And when a book is as long as this one (691 pages) and the "thriller" hook is this uncompelling, you might find yourself losing patience faster than you can say The Name of the Rose. -- Salon

    More Reviews and Recommendations

    Biography

    Like his popular “art history mysteries,” Iain Pears’s erudite historical novels are as well researched and intricately plotted as they are suspenseful and colorful. With 1998's The Instance of the Fingerpost, his first break from the art-centered Jonathan Argyll series, Pears evoked the most rapturous praise of his career.

    More About the Author

    Customer Reviews

    A Brilliant Bookby jaimi1

    Reader Rating:
    See Detailed Ratings

    September 19, 2009: This book could be read for either its political content or as a mystery or both! I refused to stop reading this book and it was exciting as well as challenging. I absolutely love the author's style of writing.

    I Also Recommend: The Shadow of the Wind, The Club Dumas, The Dream of Scipio.

    Not Really for Mystery Fansby KokoOH

    Reader Rating:
    See Detailed Ratings

    April 07, 2009: Oh, where do I start? While I really love books about history, this book made me tired. There was way too much history and not enough plot. By the time I got to the second and third sections I forgot some of the characters(there were so many) and I had to keep going back to see who they were. I've read books that have been this long and longer, but instead of 725 pages, this book could have been done in 350, no more than 400. For all of the build up, I expected a much more exciting ending. I do not recommend this book to mystery fans, maybe to historians.


    More Customer Reviews